Have you tried seeing where you are daily calorie wise. I don't think you need to track all the macros per say, but seeing what puts big hits to you calories and what doesn't is kind of an eye opener. You will loose weight targeting 2100-2500 calories a day average, even without the peloton. Obviously the number would be different for those of a different weight class. We are close to the same size. On top of calories I am targeting >135g of protein, >25g fiber, and >64 oz of straight water (separate from whatever else I drink).
A little nut bar is 190 calories. That is a quarter of the calories of a FULL plate of chicken, black beans, and rice. Half of 3 eggs with a cup of ground turkey. Every silver bullet is 102 calories and no good nutrition. 7 beers is equal to a full meal without all the good stuff. So if you are doing 7 beers and a 3 full meals... I am not saying you need to stop beers, I am saying you need to take those calories into account by eating less around it.
If you have good insurance, they want you to get to a better BMI. Mine covers my dietitian / the app to track my calories. They also covered most my blood panel. I did get a extra hormone panel which was $275, but I could have got the basic panel for free. It might have to be prescribed by a doctor for insurance to kick in.